LookLeisure is ad-free, by clicking and purchasing through our links, we may earn an affiliate commission that helps support us. Read More >

If you’re a first baseman in softball, you know that your glove is one of the most important tools at your disposal. A quality glove can mean the difference between making an out or costing your team a run. But with so many options available on the market today, finding the right softball first base glove can be a daunting task.

In this blog post, we’ll walk you through the key features to look for when selecting a glove, as well as provide a list of our top picks. Whether you’re a seasoned veteran or just starting out, by the end of this guide, you’ll have all the information you need to make an informed decision and boost your game to the next level.

Are you a first baseman looking for the perfect glove?

We know finding just the right glove can be an overwhelming process with so many options out there. That’s why we’ve put together this guide to help you find the best softball first base mitt. You’ll learn about the key features to look for and get our top picks – so you don’t have to scour through dozens of reviews online. 

With all that information in your pocket, you’ll be able to make those softball gloves yours in no time! And if you happen to pick up one of our suggestions, well, we think it’s safe to say that good things are coming your way! 

Read our blog post now and find out which is the best softball first base glove for YOU!

BEST OVERALL
MARUCCI Palmetto M-Type Fastpitch Glove Series
9.8
  • Pro-level first base mitts with premium steerhide leather
  • Ultimate comfort with memory foam finger lining and supple leather palm
  • Designed for perfect fit and fielding control
  • Professional-grade with rawhide laces and deep pocket design
PREMIUM CHOICE
Rawlings Liberty Advanced Fastpitch Softball Glove
9.6
  • Be a first base superstar with the Liberty Advanced 13″ Fastpitch Softball Glove
  • Ideal for high school to professional first basemen
  • Quality full-grain leather ensures long-lasting use and a comfortable fit
  • Pull-strap closures allow for an ideal fit for any hand size

BEST VALUE
Mizuno MVP Prime Fastpitch Softball First Base Mitt
9.3
  • Outlined, embroidered logo adds a premium touch
  • Same professional-grade lace used in our top-level gloves
  • Natural design centers the pocket under the index finger for versatile break-in
  • Perfect balance of oil and softness for ultimate feel and control.

How We Choose

Finding the right softball first base glove can be a real challenge. With so many styles, sizes, and brands to choose from, it can be hard to know where to start.

It’s easy to get overwhelmed by all of the options out there or just grab the first one you find. But if you don’t get the right glove, your play may suffer and you won’t be as successful on the field.

That’s why we’ve done the research for you and rounded up our top picks for the best softball first base gloves! You’ll have confidence knowing that you’re geared up with exactly what you need to dominate on the diamond.

 FYI — LookLeisure may collect a share of sales or other compensation from affiliate links.

PREMIUM CHOICE
Rawlings | Liberty Advanced Fastpitch Softball Glove Series
9.6
  • Control and comfort with finger back adjustments for hand size
  • Enhanced performance with Looped Modified Trap-Eze Web and Poron XRD Palm Padding
  • Durable yet comfortable with quality full-grain leather
  • Ideal fit with pull-strap closures for any hand size
  • Quick break-in with 70% factory and 30% player break-in.

Why We Love It

If you’re looking for a top-quality softball glove that offers unmatched comfort, durability, and performance, then look no further than the Rawlings Liberty Advanced Fastpitch Softball Glove Series. Designed specifically for first base players, this 13-inch fastpitch softball glove gives players the confidence to stretch, scoop, and field throws better than ever before. It’s the perfect choice for avid players from high school to the pros who demand the very best.

Perfect Fit and Comfort

Thanks to its pull-strap closures, each player can find the perfect fit for their hand. The Rawlings Liberty Advanced Fastpitch Softball Glove Series is also designed with a hand opening and finger back adjustments that accommodate the fastpitch player. This means that female athletes will enjoy an improved level of control and comfort while playing.

Unmatched Durability and Performance

Constructed with quality full-grain leather and Poron XRD palm padding, this softball glove offers quick and easy break-in with a 70% factory and 30% player break-in ratio. It features a looped modified trap-eze web, finger shift design, and pull-strap back closure, which works together to advance the fastpitch game and provide an upgraded level of performance.

In summary, the Rawlings Liberty Advanced Fastpitch Softball Glove Series is the go-to glove for serious female softball first baseman. It provides the perfect combination of fit, comfort, durability, and performance. If you want to take your game to the next level, then get your hands on this amazing glove today!

BEST VALUE
Mizuno MVP Prime Fastpitch Softball First Base Mitt
9.3
  • Outlined, embroidered logo adds a premium touch
  • Same professional-grade lace used in our top-level gloves
  • Natural design centers the pocket under the index finger for versatile break-in
  • Mizuno MVP Prime FP series designed specifically for female first baseman
  • Bio Soft Leather provides perfect balance of oil and softness for ultimate feel and control.

Why We Love It

The Mizuno MVP Prime Fastpitch Softball First Base Mitt is a top-of-the-line mitt designed for the serious fastpitch player. It is handcrafted with Bio Soft Leather, which is a professional style smooth leather that has the perfect balance of oil and softness for exceptional feel and firm control that serious players demand.

Premium Design

This first base mitt features an outlined, embroidered logo that gives it a rich, premium look. It is designed with professional-level lace that ensures the glove’s durability and longevity, making it a reliable choice for avid players.

Mizuno MVP Prime Fastpitch Softball First Base Mitt

Center Pocket Designed Patterns

The center pocket designed patterns in this glove allows for the most versatile break-in possible. The pattern design naturally centers the pocket under your pointer finger, ensuring that the glove is perfectly aligned for the best possible performance. This feature makes the Mizuno MVP Prime Fastpitch Softball First Base Mitt a great option for any serious fastpitch player.

If you’re looking for a high-quality first base mitt that offers an exceptional feel, firm control, and versatile break-in, then the Mizuno MVP Prime Fastpitch Softball First Base Mitt is a perfect choice. With its premium design, professional-level lace, and center pocket design patterns, this glove is sure to elevate your game to the next level. Get yours today and experience the difference!

Rawlings | R9 Fastpitch Softball Glove Series
9.3
  • Soft, durable all-leather shells
  • Cushioned palm padding with pull-strap closure for impact protection and custom fit
  • Basket web design, 12-inch model
  • High-quality full-grain leather for durability
  • 80% factory break-in for a game-ready feel right away

Why We Love It

If you’re a serious fastpitch player looking for an ultra-premium glove that offers exceptional durability, comfort, and impact protection, then look no further than the Rawlings R9 Fastpitch Softball Glove Series. This series features soft, durable all-leather shells designed to be game-ready, making it the best glove on the market at this price point.

Improved Fit and Protection

The Rawlings R9 Fastpitch Softball Glove Series features leather cushioned palm padding that provides impact protection for your hand during gameplay. Additionally, the pull-strap closures allow for a custom fit on any hand size, ensuring that the glove fits snugly and comfortably. The improved fit makes it easier for players to catch and hold onto the ball during gameplay.

Quick and Easy Break-In

This glove is designed to be game-ready with a quick, easy break-in process, thanks to its quality full-grain leather construction and 80% factory break-in ratio. This means that the glove will be ready to use right out of the box, allowing players to focus on their game and not on breaking in their new glove.

The Rawlings R9 Fastpitch Softball Glove Series is the perfect choice for any serious fastpitch player who demands the very best in durability, comfort, and impact protection. With its soft, durable all-leather shells, leather cushioned palm padding, pull-strap closures, and quick and easy break-in process, this glove has everything you need to take your game to the next level. Don’t settle for anything less than the best, get your Rawlings R9 Fastpitch Softball Glove today!

ALSO GREAT
Rawlings | Heart of The Hide Fastpitch Softball Glove
9.5
  • Designed for female athletes with attention to detail
  • 12 inch fastpitch model with basket web
  • Made from top steer hides and leather laces
  • Padded thumb loops and pull-strap closures for customized fit
  • 80% factory break-in for game-ready feel

Why We Love It

The Rawlings Heart of the Hide fastpitch softball gloves are every female athlete’s dream come true. Designed with more attention to detail than ever before, these gloves provide the perfect fit for the female hand.

Perfect Fit for Female Athletes

The Heart of the Hide fastpitch series gloves are tailored to the female athlete’s hand. The hand openings, finger stalls, palm padding, and patterns provide a customized fit that softball players have never experienced before.

Game-Ready Gloves

These softball gloves are 80% broken in at the factory, so they require minimal player effort to ensure they are game-ready. This makes them ideal for avid players from elite level travel ball to the pros.

The Heart of the Hide fastpitch softball gloves from Rawlings are made from top steer hides and feature pro-grade leather laces and padded thumb sleeves, making them strong, durable, and comfortable. The improved pull-strap closures at the wrist provide an even more customized fit, making these gloves a must-have for any elite female player.

Easton | Professional Collection Fastpitch Softball Glove
9.4
  • Made with Premium Reserve USA steer hide leather and professional grade USA-tanned rawhide lace
  • Quantum Closure System with adjustable open back for a comfortable and secure fit
  • Classic cowhide palm lining for maximum comfort and feel
  • Steer hide binding enhances shape retention and glove longevity
  • Perfect for first base with Right-Hand Throw – 12.75″ Dual Bar Single Post Web

Why We Love It

Step onto the field like a pro with Easton’s 2020 Professional Fastpitch Collection ball glove. Designed for smaller hands, this glove is tailored to fit the fastpitch softball athlete and provides unmatched comfort, feel, and durability.

Professional Quality

Easton’s 2020 Professional Fastpitch Collection ball glove is played by Andrea Duran, Haylie McCleney, Jolene Henderson, Kirsti Merritt, Nadia Taylor, and Nicole Dewitt. The glove is meticulously crafted with Premium Reserve USA steer hide leather and pro grade rawhide laces for extra pocket durability.

Easton’s 2020 Professional Fastpitch Collection

Customized Fit

The Quantum Closure System, combined with smaller hand openings specific for female softball players, is fully adjustable for optimized fit and feel as well as a tighter, more secure fit with improved control. The adjustable pull-tab wrist closure adds to the customized fit.

This Right-Hand Throw – 12.75″ Dual Bar Single Post Web glove is perfect for first base. The full leather lining maximizes comfort and break-in memory, while the steer hide binding and welting enhances shape retention and glove longevity. The classic cowhide palm lining provides maximum comfort and feel. The moisture-wicking wrist lining pad ensures players stay cool, dry, and comfortable while making big plays.

BEST OVERALL
MARUCCI Palmetto M-Type Fastpitch Glove Series
9.8
  • Pro-style patterns designed specifically for fastpitch players
  • Premium, tight-grain steerhide leather shell for durability
  • Supple leather palm lining with added cushioning for comfort
  • Tapered hand stall provides better fit and fielding control
  • Smooth microfiber finger lining with high-density memory foam
  • M Type fit system with integrated thumb and pinky sleeves for enhanced thumb stall cushioning

Why We Love It

The MARUCCI Palmetto M-Type Fastpitch Glove Series is the perfect fit for fastpitch players. With its PRO-STYLE patterns, this glove is designed to provide maximum comfort and fielding control.

Customized Fit

The M Type fit system provides integrated thumb and pinky sleeves with enhanced thumb stall cushioning to maximize comfort and feel. The tapered hand stall provides a better fit and fielding control, making this glove ideal for fastpitch players.

Quality Materials

The Palmetto M-Type Fastpitch Glove Series is made from a premium, tight-grain steer hide leather shell and supple leather palm lining with added cushioning. The smooth microfiber finger lining with high-density memory foam adds to the glove’s comfort.

Built to last, the MARUCCI Palmetto M-Type Fastpitch Glove Series is the ultimate choice for a first baseman. Its deep shape and professional-grade rawhide laces make it long lasting – a glove you can rely on season after season. And with options for both right-hand throw and left-hand throw players, this glove offers a customized fit for a variety of athletes. For fastpitch players in search of quality materials and a durable design, the MARUCCI Palmetto M-Type Fastpitch Glove Series is a must-have.

ALSO GREAT
Louisville Slugger 2019 LXT Fastpitch Glove
9.6
  • Dual Post Web construction for quick ball transfer and superior ball retention
  • Adjustable wrist strap offers a custom fit for comfort and support
  • Full-grain steerhide leather provides unmatched durability and softness
  • Female-specific design with patterns made for women elevates your game
  • Stylish grey and metallic gold design adds a touch of personality to your gear.

Why We Love It

The Louisville Slugger 2019 LXT Fastpitch Glove is the perfect glove for female athletes who demand the highest level of performance and comfort from their gear. With an 11.75″ infield model, dual post web construction, full-grain steer hide leather, adjustable wrist strap, and a stylish grey and metallic gold design, the Louisville Slugger LXT Fastpitch Glove has everything you need to play your best.

Dual Post Web Construction

The LXT Fastpitch Glove features a dual post web construction, which helps to create a deep pocket that will give you better ball control and quick transfers. This web design is perfect for infielders who need to react quickly to ground balls and make plays.

Adjustable Wrist Strap

The adjustable wrist strap ensures a customized fit that provides superior comfort and security. This feature keeps the glove in place during play, allowing players to focus on the game and make winning plays.

The Louisville Slugger 2019 LXT Fastpitch Glove is a top choice for female athletes who demand long-lasting and high-performance gear. With its dual post web construction, adjustable wrist strap, and full-grain steerhide leather, this glove is sure to stand the test of time. And with a stylish grey and metallic gold design, it’s easy to see why this glove is a favorite among top players and has established itself as one of the best gloves in fastpitch.

Whether you’re a seasoned athlete or just starting out, the Louisville Slugger LXT Fastpitch Glove is an excellent investment that will benefit you season after season.

FAQs

When it comes to selecting a first base mitt, there are several features that set high quality gloves apart from other fastpitch softball gloves. First and foremost, consider the size of the glove – it should fit comfortably and securely on your hand, with options available for both adult and youth players.

Another key feature to look for is the construction materials. High-quality gloves typically have leather palms combined with synthetic backs for a comfortable yet durable design that can withstand intensive use. Additionally, look for gloves with a deep pocket shape and sturdy webbing between fingers, which provides additional support when catching tough balls from right field.

Finally, pay attention to adjustability and break-in time. Some gloves come with specialized adjustment systems, while others may require dampening overnight and breaking in through use. Whatever your preference, a well-made mitt will significantly improve your defensive range and comfort in the field, leading to fewer errors during gameplay. Invest in a high quality glove that is built to last and enjoy the benefits of a reliable piece of equipment season after season. Happy shopping!

Choosing the right size softball first base glove is a serious decision. If it’s too big, it won’t provide enough control and if it’s too small, you’ll be unable to get a good grip on the ball. Here are some tips to help you make the right choice:

1. Measure your hand width – Measure from the base of your pinky finger to your thumb while making a fist – this will give you an indication of what size glove works for you.

2. Make sure you can close the glove – You want your glove to fit snugly so that when closed, all of your fingers should touch each other or overlap slightly depending on their length and width. It should also be able to close all the way so there is no extra room for miscellaneous items like laces, keys, or pocket change!

3. Check out different brands and materials – Different brands use different materials and construction techniques which may impact how easily they adapt to fit a range of sizes and shapes. Shop around for options that best meet both your needs as well as budget constraints!

4. Try out several gloves before purchasing one – Baseball stores usually carry demo models so make sure you try on several gloves until you find one that feels comfortable in terms of material, weight distribution as well as fitment around fingers, palms, and wrists!

Breaking in a first base mitt can be a great way to get it ready for game time. It may take some time and effort, but if done correctly you’ll have an awesome glove that’s perfectly molded to your hand! Here are the steps I recommend taking:

1. Start by wetting down the leather of your mitt with warm water and rubbing some oils into it like petroleum jelly or almond oil. This will help soften up the leather which will make it easier for your fingers to move inside when you break it in properly. 

2. Put your hand inside of the glove, and make sure all 4 fingers fit comfortably with enough space around each finger so they won’t feel too snug when you close them together later on. 

3. Close your hand as if you’re making a fist (maintaining comfort) and then press down on each individual fingertip from above with both hands until the leather feels shaped to that particular shape (this should take about 10 seconds). Repeat this process around 5-10 times per finger until there’s no more stiffness left in them when pressed down from above directly onto the fingertips at different angles. You can also do this by using a balled-up sock or newspaper inside instead of your hand as well, however, I find this method tends to work best because you get more control over how much pressure is applied during this process which means better results overall! 

4. Continue massaging every square inch of the entire glove until all parts are completely worked out and pliable including areas like thumb loops wrist straps, etc. This step will take longer than others and requires patience but is worth it in order for everything fit nicely once broken in properly – if time permits try doing 2 rounds of massage lasting 10 minutes each! After completing these steps you should now have a perfectly broken-in first base mitt just waiting for those big plays at game time 🙂

Finding the Best Softball First Base Glove

Picking the right softball first base glove can be a lengthy process. All of the options out there can be overwhelming at times but if you take your time and read our reviews, you’ll find that finding the perfect fit for your game will happen easier than you expect. Remember, if you look for features such as craftsmanship, break-in time, and size, then you won’t go wrong with any choice you make. Softball requires a special type of glove to make sure your first base playing is on point. Having the right glove is essential to make sure no runner shows up safe when they challenge your bases.